Pain in the buttock that travels down the leg is often called “sciatica”. But not all buttock and leg pain comes from the sciatic nerve. Tight muscles, the hip and the joints of the lower back can all send pain into the same area.
Knowing the difference helps you understand what’s going on, and what’s likely to help. For a broader overview, see our article What Is Sciatica and What Can I Do About It?
Two types of leg pain
1. Nerve-related pain (true sciatica)
This happens when a nerve root in the lower back is irritated or pressed on, often by a disc. Common signs include:
- pain that travels below the knee, sometimes into the foot
- sharp, burning, shooting or “electric” pain
- pins and needles or numbness in the leg or foot
- leg pain that is worse than the back pain
- pain that flares when you cough, sneeze or bend forward
- in some cases, weakness in the leg or foot
2. Referred pain from muscles or joints
Muscles like the glutes and piriformis, the sacroiliac joint and the small joints of the lower back can all refer pain into the buttock and thigh. Common signs include:
- a dull, deep ache rather than sharp, shooting pain
- pain that often stays above the knee
- no pins and needles or numbness
- tender spots in the buttock that feel familiar when pressed
- pain that changes with certain positions, like sitting on a hard chair or standing on one leg
Why it’s not always clear-cut
These patterns overlap. A tight glute can sit alongside an irritated nerve. And pain can change from week to week. That’s why self-diagnosis often leads to the wrong stretches, or to stretching an irritated nerve harder than it likes.
How we tell the difference
At your first visit, we take a detailed history. Then we use simple, hands-on tests, such as:
- straight leg raise and slump tests, which gently tension the nerve to see if it reproduces your leg pain
- reflex, strength and sensation checks, to see how the nerve is working
- movement and muscle tests for the lower back, hip and glutes
Together, these help us work out where your pain is most likely coming from. Then we explain it in plain English.
What may help in the meantime
- Keep moving gently within comfort. Many people find short walks feel better than long periods of rest.
- Change position often if sitting aggravates your pain.
- Avoid pushing hard into stretches that bring on sharp, shooting or tingling leg pain.
When to seek urgent help
Go to your nearest emergency department straight away if you have back or leg pain with any of these:
- new trouble controlling your bladder or bowels
- numbness around your groin, inner thighs or bottom
- weakness in your leg or foot that is quickly getting worse
How we help at The Chiro Lab
Sciatica and disc injuries are a special interest of our chiropractor, Dr Jeremy Balbin. Once we know where your pain is coming from, care may include chiropractic adjustments, soft tissue therapy, dry needling, rehab exercises and, where suitable, non-surgical spinal decompression. If you’ve had a scan, bring it along. Our guide to reading your disc report is a good place to start.
We see people from Caulfield, Elsternwick, Glen Huntly, Carnegie, Bentleigh and nearby suburbs. No referral needed.